← Back to PYQsUPSC2023

"Technology and Governance: Rewriting the Rules of the State"

Theme: Technology125 Marks • 1200 Words
👑Audio Reader (LOCKED)
Unlock with PRO
High-Authority Quotes

"Good governance is not a luxury. It is a basic right that every citizen deserves."

Nandan Nilekani

"Technology is neither good nor bad; nor is it neutral. It is a mirror of the society that creates it."

Melvin Kranzberg

"Recall the face of the poorest and weakest man you have seen and ask yourself if the step you contemplate is going to be of any use to him."

Mahatma Gandhi

"The best way to find yourself is to lose yourself in the service of others."

Mahatma Gandhi
Keywords
E-GovernanceDigital GovernanceDBTJAM TrinityAadhaarMGNREGAPDSNICNeGPDigital IndiaUMANGGeMCoWINRTIAccountabilityTransparencyLast Mile DeliveryDigital DivideSurveillance CapitalismDPDP ActSovereign AINolan PrinciplesUNDESAE-ReadinessOpen DataPrivacyEdward SnowdenAlgorithmic GovernanceConstitutional SafeguardsSmart Governance

INTRODUCTION

In 2011, the Supreme Court of India delivered a damning verdict. It called the Public Distribution System a system riddled with leakages and corruption. Across India, 40 to 60 percent of subsidised food grain never reached the poor. Ghost beneficiaries multiplied. Ration cards were duplicated. Middlemen extracted their toll at every step. A similar rot had infected MGNREGA. Payments worth thousands of crores were siphoned to fake job cards. Workers who had laboured in the sun waited months for wages that simply vanished. The state was spending. The poor were not receiving. The governance pipeline was broken.

Introduction

In 2011, the Supreme Court of India delivered a damning verdict. It called the Public Distribution System a system riddled with leakages and corruption. Across India, 40 to 60 percent of subsidised food grain never reached the poor. Ghost beneficiaries multiplied. Ration cards were duplicated. Middlemen extracted their toll at every step. A similar rot had infected MGNREGA. Payments worth thousands of crores were siphoned to fake job cards. Workers who had laboured in the sun waited months for wages that simply vanished. The state was spending. The poor were not receiving. The governance pipeline was broken.

Then something changed. The government used technology to fix what administration alone could not. Aadhaar linked real identities to welfare accounts. Direct Benefit Transfer removed every intermediary. MGNREGA payments began reaching workers directly into their Jan Dhan accounts. PDS reforms used point of sale devices and biometric verification to ensure only genuine beneficiaries received grain. States like Chhattisgarh, Andhra Pradesh, and Rajasthan showed that leakage could be brought from 60 percent to under 10 percent. Technology had done in two years what decades of administrative reform had failed to achieve.

Thesis Statement

Technology in governance is the most consequential reform of our era. It is not a supplement to good government. It is the condition that makes good government possible at scale. It converts opaque systems into transparent ones. It replaces patronage with entitlement. It turns the citizen from a supplicant into a principal. This essay argues that the integration of technology into governance is essential for administrative efficiency, social justice, constitutional accountability, and national sovereignty.

I. The Evolution of Technology and Governance: From Clay Tablets to Digital Dashboards

Yuval Noah Harari, in Sapiens, observes that the first governments emerged from the need to manage information. The ancient Sumerians did not invent writing for poetry. They invented it to track grain, taxes, and labour. Governance has always been an information management problem. Every technology that improved information management changed the nature of governance.

II. Digital Governance and Transformation: Rewriting the Rules of the State

The UNDESA E-Government Survey 2022 defines transformative e-governance as the use of digital tools not merely to automate existing processes but to redesign how public services are conceived, delivered, and evaluated. Direct Benefit Transfer is the most consequential example. Since 2013, DBT has transferred over Rs 33 lakh crore directly to citizens, eliminating thousands of crores in annual leakage.

III. Administrative Efficiency, Accountability, and Last Mile Delivery: The Honest Machine

The Nolan Committee (1994) in the UK established seven principles of public life. Technology does not replace these principles; it enforces them structurally. A system designed with transparency baked in does not depend on an individual officer's integrity. It makes dishonesty harder than honesty.

IV. Social, Economic, and Political Impact: Technology as the Great Equaliser

Technology in governance is an attempt to honour the broken promise of inclusion. DIKSHA carries curriculum content in 36 languages and has served 30 crore students. PM-JANMAN uses digital profiling to reach Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups. Economically, GST and digital invoicing brought 1.4 crore businesses into the formal economy.

V. Constitutional Vision and the Role of Technology in Governance: Serving the Republic

The Preamble of the Indian Constitution promises justice, liberty, equality, and fraternity. Every digital institution must be measured against these commands. Justice requires access; the e-Courts Mission has digitised case management across 18,000 courts.

VI. India and Technology in Governance: The World's Largest Democratic Experiment

India's digital governance architecture is now its most credible export. The India Stack - Aadhaar, UPI, DigiLocker, ABDM, and ONDC - is the most sophisticated digital public infrastructure in the world. The World Bank calls India's Aadhaar-based DBT system the gold standard.

VII. Issues and Problems: When Technology Governs Without Wisdom

Technology without wisdom creates serious hidden risks. Edward Snowden's revelations showed how governments can misuse data. Facial recognition is now used by 16 states without a strong legal framework. When the governing state becomes a surveillance state, citizens lose their democratic autonomy.

Conclusion

A woman in Jharkhand now receives her MGNREGA wages without a single intermediary. A child in Rajasthan's Barmer district reads DIKSHA content in Marwari on a tablet. These are not small victories. They are civilisational corrections. They repair, one transfer at a time, the promises that independent India made to its people in 1947.

Technology does not govern. People govern. Design it with justice, and it delivers justice at scale. Technology in governance is India's way of losing itself in the service of 1.4 billion citizens. That is not a programme. That is a vow.

Unlock Solved Essay (Free Account)

Log in or create a free account to read the complete solved essay and play the audio narration.